The short answer
Neither option is universally better. The road, the distance and the length of the trip decide more than the price alone, and a week in one city is not a two-week circuit.
- Short distances, one city, plans that change by the hour: rent.
- Long intercity legs, mountain roads, late arrivals after flights: driver.
- You enjoy driving and want the keys on your terms: rent.
- You want to look out of the window rather than at the road: driver.
- Two people, light luggage, city hopping: either works.
- Family with bags, desert camps, early starts: driver.




